Halloween Mummy Jalapeño Poppers: An Easy Grilled Party Appetizer

Give your Halloween appetizer tray a little personality with mummy jalapeño poppers. Each pepper half gets a creamy cheddar filling, a wrapping of crescent dough and two tiny olive eyes.

These Halloween jalapeño poppers cook on a baking sheet over indirect grill heat, giving you an easy way to keep the party outdoors. The pastry turns golden while the filling becomes warm and creamy.

Prefer a milder bite? Swap the jalapeños for mini sweet peppers and keep the same mummy wrapping.

Recipe Details

Yield: 16 poppers
Servings: 8, allowing 2 poppers per person
Prep time: Approximately 25 minutes
Cooking time: Approximately 18–25 minutes
Total time: Approximately 50 minutes, plus grill preheating

Ingredients

• 8 large jalapeños
• 6 ounces cream cheese, softened
• 3/4 cup shredded sharp cheddar
• 1/2 teaspoon garlic powder
• 1/4 teaspoon smoked paprika
• 2 tablespoons finely chopped chives or green onions
• 1 refrigerated crescent dough sheet or 8-ounce tube of crescent rolls
• 1 egg beaten with 1 teaspoon water, for brushing
• Approximately 8 pitted black olives, cut into 32 small pieces for eyes
• Ranch dressing or sour cream, optional, for serving

How to Make Mummy Jalapeño Poppers on the Grill

1. Prepare the Grill for Indirect Cooking

Preheat the grill to approximately 375°F, with a cooking area away from direct flame.

For a gas grill, use burners beside the cooking area while leaving the burners directly beneath the tray off. For charcoal, arrange the coals to one side and place the tray on the opposite side.

Use a rimmed metal baking sheet suitable for your grill, lightly greased or lined with foil. Keep the tray away from direct flame.

2. Prepare the Peppers

Halve the jalapeños lengthwise. Remove the seeds and white membranes, keeping the pepper halves intact.

Wear food-preparation gloves when handling hot peppers if needed, wash your hands afterward and avoid touching your eyes. Removing the membranes reduces heat, but jalapeños still vary in strength.

3. Mix the Cheese Filling

Stir together the cream cheese, cheddar, garlic powder, smoked paprika and chives until evenly combined.

Spoon the mixture into the pepper halves, keeping it roughly level with their edges. Overfilling can make wrapping difficult and encourage the cheese to spill onto the tray.

4. Cut the Pastry Bandages

Unroll the crescent dough on a lightly floured surface. If using individual crescent rolls, gently pinch the seams together to form a sheet.

Cut into thin strips approximately 1/4 inch wide. Keep the dough cool so it remains easy to handle.

5. Wrap Your Mummies

Wrap a few strips loosely around each filled pepper, crossing them at different angles. Leave small gaps between the strips and an exposed patch near the wider end for the eyes.

Avoid thick overlapping layers, which can remain doughy underneath. Tuck the strip ends beneath the pepper and place it filling-side up on the prepared tray.

Lightly brush the pastry with the egg wash.

6. Grill Until the Pastry Is Cooked Through

Place the tray over indirect heat and close the lid. Cook for approximately 18–25 minutes, rotating the tray as needed for even browning.

The pastry should be golden and cooked through, including where strips overlap, and the filling should be hot. Check early because grill temperatures and hot spots vary.

If the bottoms darken too quickly, move the tray to a cooler indirect area and reduce the heat. Never place the dough-wrapped peppers directly on the cooking grates.

7. Add the Eyes and Serve

Let the poppers cool for about 5 minutes. Press two small olive pieces into the exposed filling on each pepper to create the eyes.

Transfer to a serving platter and offer ranch dressing or sour cream alongside. Warn guests that the filling may still be hot.

Tips for Golden Pastry and Neat Mummy Wrapping

• Use larger peppers: They provide more room for filling and wrapping.
• Keep the dough cool: Refrigerate it briefly if it becomes sticky or difficult to cut.
• Wrap lightly: Thin strips with a few gaps cook more evenly than a thick pastry covering.
• Leave room on the tray: The dough expands as it cooks.
• Watch the bottoms: Indirect heat helps prevent scorching while the pastry bakes.
• Add olive eyes afterward: They are easier to position once the pastry has set.

Make a Mild Sweet-Pepper Version

Replace the jalapeños with similarly sized mini sweet peppers. Halve them, remove the seeds and fill and wrap as directed.

Smaller peppers may need less filling and shorter cooking time. Start checking early and use the pastry’s doneness as your guide.

If serving both versions, label the platters so guests can choose their preferred heat level.

Easy Variations

Add Cooked Bacon

Stir a few tablespoons of finely chopped, fully cooked bacon into the cheese mixture. Do not use raw bacon in the filling.

Try Pepper Jack

Replace some or all of the cheddar with pepper jack for a different flavor and additional heat.

Keep the Garnish Savory

Small black olive pieces make simple edible eyes. Avoid adding candy eyes unless you specifically want a sweet-and-savory combination.

Make-Ahead Tips

Prepare the cheese filling and cleaned pepper halves up to one day ahead. Store separately in covered containers in the refrigerator.

Fill and wrap close to cooking time for easier dough handling. If assembling a few hours ahead, keep the tray covered and refrigerated, then allow additional cooking time if needed.

These poppers are best enjoyed shortly after cooking, when the pastry is crisp and the filling is creamy.

Oven Instructions

Heat the oven to 375°F. Arrange the wrapped poppers on a prepared baking sheet and bake for approximately 18–25 minutes, until the dough is golden and cooked through.

Add the olive eyes after a brief cooling period, just as you would for the grilled version.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are mummy jalapeño poppers very spicy?

The heat varies with the peppers. Removing the seeds and white membranes helps, but does not guarantee a mild result. Use mini sweet peppers for a gentler alternative.

Can I use crescent rolls instead of a dough sheet?

Yes. Pinch the perforated seams together before cutting the dough into thin strips.

Can I put these directly on the grill grates?

Use a suitable metal baking sheet over indirect heat. Direct contact with the grates can burn the pastry or allow filling to fall through.

How do I keep the dough from being raw underneath?

Avoid thick overlaps, keep the grill at a steady baking temperature and check the pastry around the sides as well as the top. Continue cooking over indirect heat until the dough is fully baked.

What should I serve with Halloween jalapeño poppers?

Ranch dressing or sour cream makes an easy dip. Add a mild appetizer option alongside them so guests who avoid spicy food have a choice.

A Little Spooky, Plenty Cheesy

These mummy jalapeño poppers bring a playful Halloween look to a familiar appetizer. Set out a warm platter, keep a mild version nearby and let guests choose their favorite little mummy.

For a comfortable backyard gathering space, explore Sunzout’s poly dining furniture and deep seating options.